CATDOLL: Only original animation can show real skills? Adapted animation director is caught in the crossfire

In Japan, a large number of new animations are released every season, most of which are adapted from existing comics, light novels, or games. However, there are also some original animations in each season, many of which are excellent. Nowadays, some anime fans not only look at the plot, voice actors, and character settings when choosing an animation, but also often add the director's name. Therefore, some people believe that making original works reflects the level of the work, and published this statement on the Internet. As a result, this statement immediately caused heated discussions among netizens. Some comments are as follows:

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

The original work is the work of りきのThe original work is の力ってものがあるからな

The animation adapted from the original work will also contain some of the power of the original work.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

The original work of the chef is the maggot bug and the skill is the same.

Don't ignore the power of the original fans who are just spraying nonsense.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

どう卡えても神に小くせざるを得ないのに

シーンカットに文物语う马鹿 original chef を黙らせんの大変だろ

Some works have to cut the plot no matter how you think about it, and the director is really trying hard to shut up those idiot fans of the original work who keep complaining about the cut scenes.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

ラノベや novel みたいな text media をアニメーションにして success させるのは ordinary にpathetic いと思う

I think that being able to successfully convert a text medium like a light novel or novel into an animation is amazing in itself.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

Integrity and good nature, the original work of the original novel

Supervised and scripted by だれか Tuned by べて覚 Completed by した方が Mental Health Shangliang いよね

Color glasses を抜きにすればちゃんと美点やOriginal work を日えているところが多々あっても

Refusal to retaliate

Honestly, when a favorite original work is adapted into an animation, from a spiritual level, it is better to first check who the director and the script are, and then watch it with awareness. As long as you take off your tinted glasses, you will find many highlights and parts that surpass the original. If you resist the animation adaptation, you will not be able to see these features.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

ただ、オリジナルぶっこんだらOriginal workファンがキレるからな……

The other thing is the same as the original one. The original one is the same as the original one.

Example: Toei version of kanon, the main character is をスケコマシにしないように

また三つの愿いという Limitation を evil devil しないよう constitute したのに后年黑歴史扱いされてるし

However, if original content is added to the adapted work, fans of the original will go crazy... It cannot be viewed as any other work, and the same satisfaction as the original cannot be obtained, so many people will definitely feel that it has lost points... For example, the Toei version of "Kanon" was made like this in order to prevent the protagonist from looking like a playboy and not to affect the restriction of the three wishes, but it was later regarded as a black history.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

The original work is written by の好さを生かしてアニメ化できるsupervised by も灄と思うぞ

The original work of the reverse is good and the students are born.

Original work: じゃないレベルの事をしでかしたsupervised by は目も道てられないが

I think a good animation director is someone who can flexibly show the strengths of the original work. On the contrary, I look down on those directors who can't do that or even rape the original work.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

そもそもアニメsupervised ってspecific にやってるんだかよく分からん俺

ストーリーが好かったならScript writer すごい!ってなるし

絵が好かったらIllustrated by すごい!ってなるしでsupervised by を褒めるタイミングが见つからん

In the final analysis, I have no idea what an animation director does specifically. If the plot is great, then the screenwriter must be great! If the graphics are great, then the painter must be great! I can't find any opportunity to praise the director.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

The new house in front of the house is the new house

His work is a single piece of work

Shinbo from the past few years was quite impressive. As for the others, in terms of the works themselves, the "Shiba-dan Mythos Series" had a great impact on me.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

ハーレム&俺TUEEEEEEE&ご都合覚 Wake と言うHow にも

お前らの叩きそうなものが揃ったウィッチクラフトワークスを作り上げ

The one who is still holding the upper hand is the one who is doing the work and is out of the water.

I would like to nominate Mizushima Tsutomu. He combined the harem, the dragon king, the awakening that facilitates the plot, and other elements that you have criticized to pieces to create "Witch's Mission", and made the work reach a high degree of completion.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

There are capable supervisors for Nusuke, Mizushima Seiji, On the way, and Tsurugi.

Anu is indeed amazing, but Seiji Mizushima was also able to make "Fullmetal Alchemist", which was adapted halfway into an original plot, very interesting, which is incredible.

Mingmae: Mingwu しさん Submission date: April 24, 2015

Urobuchi script とかつまんねえじゃん

People are dying and they are happy in the kitchen?

Someone mentioned the script above. Urobuchi's script is boring. It can only be aimed at those fans who like dead people, right?