CATDOLL: Why is the manga "One Punch Man" so attractive and considered the ultimate work?

The animation "One Punch Man" aired last year can be said to have attracted great attention from anime fans. Now people are not only paying attention to the well-made animation, but also starting to pay attention to the comics themselves. However, some people still don't know that there are two versions of the original comics, one is the original version drawn by ONE teacher, and the other is the more familiar improved version made by Murata teacher. Recently, a Japanese netizen posted: "One Punch Man is really the ultimate work", why is this? Everyone also expressed their opinions below.

ONE's drawing skills are terrible, but his works are popular; Murata's drawing style is great, but he is not famous. The combination of these two people has produced a work that is both interesting and good in style. It seems that "One Punch Man" is really an ultimate work that combines the ultimate plot and the ultimate drawing.

Murata's version of One Punch Man

ONE's original work, very stylish...

Actually, I personally prefer ONE's hopeless style. It basically reflects the characteristics of the characters, and caters to the theme of "this is actually a funny comic". Murata's improved version is a little too handsome, which makes it less interesting.

It is not enough to just consider this work as a comedy comic. In the plot of Deep Sea King, the teacher deliberately vilified himself in order not to embarrass other heroes. This is probably not a theme that should appear in a comedy comic. The contrast between the indifferent public and the teacher who seems to be indifferent to everything but is actually very kind-hearted... This is what I think is the ultimate part of the work.

ONE's style of painting gives people the feeling that "this thing is completely fictional", but Murata adds some sense of reality. The plot of Deep Sea King mentioned above is actually not as good as Murata's in ONE's work.

ONE's version is more like a game of life, it's like a paper man saving the world. In Murata's work, the teacher has a stronger heroic temperament. Well, to each his own!

　　If readers have read both versions of the comics, they will find that the two versions of the comic "One Punch Man" really have their own merits, but even though the styles are completely different, the funny and passionate plots are really the same. A work that can achieve this is really not an exaggeration to be called the "ultimate" work.