CATDOLL: Media refutes Beijing TV's criticism of "Detective Conan": Tearing apart Japanese soldiers with bare hands is more bloody and violent than anime

Some time ago, the "Legal System in Progress" program on the Science and Education Channel of Beijing Television made a program criticizing the content of illegal animation. Among them, "Detective Conan" was called a "crime textbook". The report emphasized the harm of violent and bloody animation to minors, and called on relevant departments to improve the relevant classification system as soon as possible.

A great detective who has been working diligently and fighting against various criminals day after day and year after year for 20 years was recently exposed as a mastermind who instigated others to commit crimes! Everyone was deceived by him! Well, this person is called Conan, Detective Conan. If Gosho Aoyama knew that his masterpiece "Detective Conan" was criticized by Beijing TV's "Rule of Law in Progress" column as "actually a naked crime textbook", it is estimated that at least thousands of beasts would gallop through his heart: Isn't this a mystery comic? What kind of mystery is it without a case?

After watching the video, I found that the "Rule of Law in Progress" roughly mentioned the following "evidence": bloody and violent plots, the whole process of planning the murder at the end of each episode, the horror content affects children's mental health, and some children imitate the plots of cartoons and cause harm. At first glance, it seems to be harmful, but think about it carefully, is it really the case?

Criticizing the bloody and violent anime is not news. I remember that more than 20 years ago when I was in junior high school, some media exclaimed that "children are keen to imitate Saint Seiya" and believed that the "Pegasus Meteor Fist" and "Lushan Shenglong Ba" on the streets would turn into collective fights. What was the result? It seems that there is not a single real case. Besides, the "hand-torn devils" that have been all over the screen in the past two years are much bloodier than just anime.

Telling the process of murder. Please look back, from CCTV's "Today's Statement" to local TV stations' "Case Focus", "Legal Online" and other brother programs are watching you. By the way, don't you also report the details of various murder, arson, gambling and drug trafficking cases? Affecting mental health. Come on, please go to Tianya Forum, there is a famous post called "Beware of Childhood Shadows!!! The above picture shows various horror scenes in the eight old versions of "Investiture of the Gods"!!! Those scenes of burning, cutting out hearts, digging out eyes, and cutting flesh were 6 years earlier than Conan.

Imitating the plot of anime and cartoons to cause harm. A quick search for "imitating TV series" yields hundreds of articles such as "imitating TV series to kill", "imitating TV series to commit suicide", and "imitating TV series to hang". It seems that "My Fair Princess", one of the "must-see TV series in summer", will not be broadcast every year, because the little girl imitated Xiaoyanzi to hang herself.

From this, can we draw the conclusion that TV programs are much more harmful than cartoons? Why don't we just shut down all TV stations? The same goes for movies. They are either about kissing and sex or about killing and hacking. If a youth film doesn't include abortion or cheating, it's embarrassing to release it. Won't it corrupt all the children? It's better to ban them all.

In fact, Beijing TV also said that there are rating systems for TV, movies, etc. abroad, and many animations are adult animations, not for children. For example, one of the evidences in the program is that on the screen of the animation "Zombie Brothers", you can see a very clear and large 18-forbidden icon, indicating that this is a work for adults over 18 years old. The main problem in China is that there is no rating system, and children can directly watch all types of animations. Therefore, the program finally called on relevant departments to introduce a complete system as soon as possible, and not rely solely on a ban to manage these "violent and terrorist comics."

The problem is that, whether it is television, movies or animation, the industry has been calling for a rating system for at least 15 years, if not 20 years, but it has never been implemented. So some people say that it seems impossible to rely on a rating system in the short term, and it is understandable to take some more stringent management measures, otherwise what will happen if children imitate these violent plots? The interesting thing is that "Rule of Law in Progress" has actually given an answer: in the information cited in the program, the screen shows a news titled "Children imitate animations and accidents frequently occur. It is dangerous to watch without teaching."

Indeed, children are very curious and like to imitate, which is determined by their psychological characteristics; but they lack the experience of adults, cannot predict the consequences of their actions, and have no intuitive understanding of "big words" such as life and death, right and wrong, which is also determined by their psychological characteristics. The rating system based on the age of the audience itself shows that people of different ages have different acceptance and understanding of things. Therefore, adults will have clear judgments after watching those bloody and violent plots, while children need guidance and education from their parents. For example, parents can comfort and relieve children's nervousness when facing more terrifying scenes, and guide children to form a sense of right and wrong when facing violent scenes, etc.

If parents are asked to choose literary works for their children, traditional classics such as the Four Great Classics are probably indispensable. However, many parents may not know that there is a saying that goes, "Young people should not read the Dream of the Red Chamber, young people should not read Water Margin, and old people should not read the Romance of the Three Kingdoms." This means that young people who read the Dream of the Red Chamber are prone to early love, young and middle-aged people who read Water Margin are prone to getting into trouble, and old people who read the Romance of the Three Kingdoms will become cunning and treacherous. However, Lu Xun also said, "A Dream of the Red Chamber has different perspectives depending on the reader. Taoists see it as easy, Confucian scholars see it as lewd, talented scholars and beautiful women see it as lingering, gossipers see it as palace secrets, and revolutionaries see it as expelling the Manchus."

Conan said: There is only one truth. What you look at is not the problem, but how you look at it is the problem.

Original news address: click here