CATDOLL: Japanese netizens graded cartoonists' drawing skills, sparking heated discussions and being criticized. Do you really understand?

There are many posts in Japan recently discussing the drawing skills of cartoonists. Previously, there was a discussion about which cartoonist has better drawing skills. Now, a netizen has made his own classification of the drawing skills of Japanese cartoonists, where SS is the highest level and G is the lowest level. He puts Kentaro Miura and Takeshi Obata at the highest level. He also thinks that cartoonists such as Kumeta Koji of "Desperate Teacher" and Chibi Maruko-chan of "Chibi Maruko-chan" have no drawing skills. As soon as this post came out, it caused a heated discussion among Japanese netizens, who believed that his classification was not scientific.

1:2016/01/01(Friday)13:10:44

SS-level: Katsuhiro Otomo (AKIRA), Kentaro Miura (Berserk), Takeshi Obata (Death Note)

S-rank: Iwaaki Hitoshi (Parasyte), Hiramoto Akira (Prison School), Murata Yusuke (One Punch Man)

A-level: Manga Taro ("Jin Yu Ji"), Yabuki Kentaro ("ToLOVE"), Araki Hirohiko (JOJO), Itagaki Keisuke ("Harabiga")

Class B: Mizuki Kawashita ("Strawberry 100%"), Yoshizaki Kannon ("KERORO Gunso"), Toshiru ("Kkindaichi"), Masuda Masuda ("Comic Comic Hiyori")

C-level: Rumiko Takahashi (Inuyasha), Masashi Kishimoto (NARUTO), Go Nagai (Mazinger Z),

D-level: Ieiro Tanabe (Kekkaishi), Kato Kazue (Ao no Exorcist), Eiichiro Oda (One Piece), CLAMP (Cardcaptor Sakura)

No painting skills at all:

Kenjiro E Hata ("The Hayate the Combat Butler"), Shinobu Otaka ("Magi")

F Kumeda Koji ("Desperate Teacher"), Sakura Maruko-chan ("Chibi Maruko-chan")

G Nobuyuki Fukumoto (Gambling Apocalypse)

2:2016/01/01(Friday)13:13:35

Kumeda Koji's lines are very beautiful

4:2016/01/01(Friday)13:14:31

Is Iwaaki Hitoshi’s painting skills that good?

5:2016/01/01(Friday)13:14:34

You said Masashi Kishimoto is C, are you kidding me?

9:2016/01/01(Friday)13:16:31

Masuda's painting skills 2333

11:2016/01/01(Friday)13:17:04

What do you think of the winter scene?

13:2016/01/01(Friday)13:17:59

Adachi Mitsuru is B, but the storyboard and lines are SSS level

14:2016/01/01(Friday)13:18:49

Author of Another Dimension: Dragon Sakura

Sorachi should be A-level.

19:2016/01/01(Friday)13:22:17

No Tetsuo Hara? Are you serious?

28:2016/01/01(Friday)13:26:16

Obata's illustrations are strong but the comics are just average

33:2016/01/01(Gold)13:29:13

Senxun is very strong

It seems that people do not agree with this netizen's ranking of cartoonists' drawing skills. Judging a cartoonist's drawing skills requires many considerations, and each cartoonist's drawing style is also unique. A cartoonist's drawing skills are good, which means his comics will be popular. People also said that many cartoonists with good drawing skills were not listed at all, and this list is rather one-sided. I wonder which other cartoonists you think have good drawing skills? Let's list them.