CATDOLL: The real scapegoat netizens complained that the decline in the quality of Japanese comics is all Jump's fault

Speaking of comics, Japanese comics are definitely worth mentioning. After all, from a long time ago to the present, it has brought us too many classic works. However, there is a phenomenon recently that makes people very depressed. Although there are really many new comics, the quality of the comics is very unsatisfactory. The number of new classic works in the comics industry is indeed relatively small. Regarding this phenomenon, a Japanese netizen put forward a point of view: "The culprit of the decline of Japanese comics is "Weekly Shonen Jump"." The reason for saying this is that he thinks that "JUMP" only focuses on making money and forcibly delays comics. This view has triggered discussions among Japanese netizens, and it seems that many netizens still agree with his point of view.

1 top: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:19:12?ID:7Jg

The culprit of the decline of Japanese manga is "JUMP", right? "Death Note" was not finished when L died. So it also values ​​money?

Top 5: Name无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:31:13?ID:7Jg

There are many works in which the first 10 to 20 volumes are really drawn with great effort, but the rest are just watered-down products forced out by the editorial department.

Top 4: Namo しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:27:00 ID:gBY

In fact, weekly serialization is quite impressive, but it is normal for the quality to decline as the serialization continues.

Top 6: Mingwu しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:33:14 ID:RjN

As a result, in order to avoid being drained of their talents by the editorial department, they either had to make a big argument like Inoue and start their own independent publication, or they could ask for leave like Togashi did...

7th place: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:33:58 ID:RjN

The only exception is Oda.

8th place: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:34:21 ID:Qf0

I'm annoyed by those who try to prolong the series

11th place: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:36:09 ID:AEI

Oda is the one who is being squeezed dry!

Top 13: Name无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:37:25 ID:iRH

Oda himself draws comics because he loves it, but if there were no editorial department, the story would probably have been completed in 5 years.

Top 15: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:38:30?ID:7Jg

Is Slam Dunk the only work that has been perfectly completed?

18th place: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:39:19 ID:CRr

Long-term serialization is the root of all evil, dragging out the story and ignoring the plot → popularity is declining and the quality of the comics is low.

Try to make the story short but still very popular. Why can't we do this now?

Top 21: Name无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:40:58 ID:iRH

Is Death still going on? It's been said for years that the plot is dragging...

Top 25: Name无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:43:04 ID:XP2

Rather than saying that Death is dragging, it’s better to say that we have no idea what the author wants to express…

79 top names: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)21:38:48 ID:AEI

I feel that Assassination Classroom is boring. It is not like Nero where we can discuss serious topics...

94 Top names: 名无しさん@おーぷん[ ]: 2015/09/12 (Tu) 01:37:18 ID:75m

Although it is not from "JUMP", "Yowamushi Pedal" should end in volume 28.

Top 35: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:51:22 ID:ZPW

Is "JOJO" a long-running but successful series?

39 top names: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:52:57 ID:XP2

After all, this is a commercial magazine, and if it is popular, it must continue to be serialized.

51 top: 名无しさん@おーぷん：2015/09/11(金)20:58:17?ID:7Jg

"Dream Eaters" says not to be influenced by readers, but what the editorial department does is completely influenced by readers.

It seems that everyone is really dissatisfied with the setting that as long as a work is popular, it cannot be concluded casually. Although the popularity of a work can indeed bring in huge income, overly procrastinating the plot will only make readers more and more disgusted. However, works like "One Piece" and "JOJO" seem to be okay, and the same is true for "Hunter x Hunter", so we still can't generalize. What do you think?