CATDOLL: Do you have to be serious? Japanese netizens discuss Luffy's attack moves that don't conform to mechanics

There are various devil fruits in the Japanese anime "One Piece". After eating them, you can gain supernatural powers. Among them, Luffy ate the rubber fruit, which allows his body to stretch freely, and he also uses this feature to fight. Many times, his battles look very cool, but recently some Japanese netizens have raised such a question: "Luffy can stretch his body freely to attack, which is not possible from a mechanical point of view?" Japanese netizens also had a heated discussion on this issue.

Top 1: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21(国) 06:32:13

Luffy can stretch his body freely to attack, which is not possible from a mechanical point of view.

Top 2: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:33:07

Aren't earthworms also able to stretch and retract their bodies?

Top 4: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:33:29

It seems that many people didn’t understand that Luffy is not rubber but a rubber man.

Top 7: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:35:19

Stretching downwards ← is understandable.

Horizontal extension←?!?!?

Stretching upwards ← ahhhhhh

Top 8: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:36:23

Because the power of the attack will be weakened by the elasticity of the rubber, he can still withstand it if it is just a normal beating.

Top 11: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21(国) 06:38:29

Let's verify them one by one. First of all, the basic skill of the rubber anti-tank gun is acceptable. It is still possible to stretch it that long by running.

Top 16: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21(国) 06:43:35

All substances can stretch and retract. Hard substances like iron and rock can still stretch under very strong external forces, but the extent of the stretch is very small. The volume of such substances will increase after stretching, but rubber is special and its volume will not change after stretching. Luffy's arm can usually stretch to about 50 meters, which means that the arm is stretched 100 times, so the cross-sectional area of ​​the arm will be reduced to one 100th of the original. If the area is calculated by "diameter × diameter", the diameter is one 10th of the original, about 8 mm, which is about the same as a pencil. Such a thin arm will make people feel uneasy.

Top 18: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:46:52

It's just a cartoon, all imaginary. It's meaningless to use reality to illustrate the issue.

Top 21: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:50:40

Rubber can stretch and contract freely, so there's no problem, right?

Top 22: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:51:25

The rubber fruit has two effects. One is to turn the body into rubber, and the other is the ability to quickly stretch the body.

Top 24: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:58:14

Wouldn't it be more powerful to use the rebound at home than to hit directly?

Top 25: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお送りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:58:45

Violates the law of conservation of mass.

Top 19: The following, \(^o^)/でVIPがお发りします: 2016/05/21 (Tu) 06:48:54

In fact, everyone knows that Luffy's rubber body is also because he ate the devil fruit, which is completely fictional. I really feel that there is no need to be too serious about this kind of unscientific anime. However, the netizens there are still quite a lot of discussions, but in the final analysis, this is the result of Luffy eating the rubber fruit.