CATDOLL: Japanese media voted for the anime that they least want to be adapted into live-action Slam Dunk and One Piece, please let them go

After a work is broadcast and has attracted crazy attention from the audience, it is definitely a good idea to make it into a live-action movie in order to continue to attract widespread attention! Such examples are not uncommon, but if the original work is too classic and the live-action version cannot surpass the original, will it disappoint the fans? So recently, the Japanese NICONICO website conducted a survey on hundreds of fans of the original work with the theme of "Works that I beg not to be adapted into live-action movies" and obtained a ranking list. Let's take a look at the animations that fans least want to see adapted into live-action movies.

Top 5 works destined to be tragic after being adapted into live-action

No. 1: Slam Dunk – 14.0%

No. 2: One Piece – 10.0%

No. 3 Neon Genesis Evangelion – 7.0%

4. Mazinger Z – 6.0%

No. 5 "JoJo's Bizarre Adventure" - 5.0%

Now I will share some wonderful answers with you and see if there will be any amazing comments among them.

The reason for answering "SLAM DUNK"

Because this work is so popular, if the live-action version is not very interesting, it will definitely be criticized. (Female / 27 years old / Metal, Steel, Chemistry)

I'm afraid I'll fail because of the wrong pairing of roles. (Female/33 years old/school and education related)

I just don’t want this work to be adapted into a live-action version (Female/27 years old/Information and IT)

The reason for One Piece's answer

I can imagine it becoming a movie full of CG. (Female/24/Information and IT)

It is really difficult to assign roles to this work, whether in Hollywood or in China. No matter what the final result is, I think it will be criticized by the public. (Female / 28 years old / Metal, Steel, Chemistry)

Unless the voice actors of the animation play the live-action version, they will definitely not be recognized by the audience. (Female/27 years old/Talent dispatch and talent introduction)

The reason for Neon Genesis Evangelion's answer

If it were adapted into a live-action film overseas, it would surely be as disappointing as the previous Dragon Ball. (Male / 43 years old / Other)

Will the muscular man Shinji-kun and the fashionable woman Ayanami Rei appear? (Male / 33 years old / Information and IT)

This work is so classic because it is an animation. If it were made into a live-action work, it would be boring and would definitely become a dark history. (Male/30 years old/Finance and Securities)

The reason for Mazinger Z's answer

Almost all live-action adaptations of the hit anime of the 70s have failed, and Mazinger Z will be no exception. (Male/45/Other)

I don’t want to watch cheap CG Mazinger Z. (Male / 39 years old / Construction and civil engineering)

Reasons for answering "JoJo's Bizarre Adventure"

Leaving aside the first and second parts, the third part will definitely be filled with CG images and become terrible. (Female/28 years old/Group/Public Interest Corporation/Government Office)

I think it will definitely be a shame. (Female/27 years old/school and education related)

The main reason for the answers was that everyone was very uneasy about the "CG scenes" of machines or action works. In addition, it is very difficult to choose actors for these works, not to mention the failure of Hollywood live-action versions. In addition, let's take a look at the works outside the top five.

Yu☆Yu☆Hakusho

This work is still very popular, so it wouldn't be surprising if it were adapted into a live-action version someday. Although it's not worth looking forward to. (Female/32 years old/Medical and Welfare)

NARUTO

I’m afraid it will become a weird CG work. It may even be criticized as not as good as Ninja Rantaro. (Male / 32 years old / Finance and Securities)

Fullmetal Alchemist

If this work is adapted into a live-action film, it will definitely require CG, but the key CG scenes will probably become very shabby and terrible. (Male/29 years old/Transportation warehouse)

The focus of everyone's concern is still the "CG" problem. If some characters whose unique personalities can only be shown in comics or animations are made into real people, it will inevitably cause dissatisfaction among the audience. Moreover, no matter how advanced CG or performance technology is, it is still impossible to fully show the world of the second dimension. So what do you think about this?